Skip to content
MS-Logo-UP
Client Reviews

1.800.481.2180

  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Blog
  • What We Do
    • Business Compliance Services
    • Business & Contracts
      • Choosing a Business Lawyer for NC Corporations and Other Small Business
      • The Number One Problem for Small Limited Liability Companies
      • How To Dissolve a Corporation in North Carolina?
      • 5 Considerations as to Your Business’ Negative Internet Review
      • (Part 2) 5 Considerations as to Your Business’ Negative Internet Review
      • (Part 3) 5 Considerations as to Your Business’ Negative Internet Review
      • (Part 4) 5 Considerations as to Your Business’ Negative Internet Review
      • (Part 5) 5 Considerations as to Your Business’ Negative Internet Review
      • Are Negative Reviews Really Bad for Business?
    • Limited Liability Company
      • Your New LLC – Part 1: The Basics
      • New LLC: Maintaining Limited Liability Protection
      • Your New LLC – Part 3: Federal, State and Local Registration, Licensing and Permitting
      • “Your New LLC” – Part 4: Transacting Business in Another State
      • “Your New LLC” – Part 5: Moving Your LLC to Another State
    • Mortgage & Foreclosure
      • Hearing Results
      • Mortgage Problems – Should You Trust Your Lender or Loan Servicer?
      • When to Hire an Attorney for Foreclosure and Mortgage Relief
      • Mortgage Loans: Recourse versus Non-Recourse and Foreclosure Related Deficiency Judgments
      • Negotiating with a Bank: Why do I have to Provide My Financials?
      • Can the HOA (Homeowners’ Association) Foreclose on my Home?
    • Real Estate Cases
      • Breach of NC Real Estate Purchase Contract – Buyer’s Damages in NorthCarolina
      • Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) – What is the Borrower Really Paying for?
    • Real Estate Closings
    • Disputes & Lawsuits
      • Business Contracts: What Should Yours Say Regarding Recovering Attorneys’ Fees in Case of Dispute? (Part 1)
      • Business Contracts: What Should Yours Say Regarding Recovering Attorneys’ Fees in Case of Dispute? (Part 2)
      • Arbitration versus Mediation
      • Responding to a Lawsuit Complaint
    • Tax & IRS Matters
      • S-Corp Tax Election for LLC
      • Comparison of Subchapter K v. Subchapter S
      • Employment Tax Considerations in Starting a Business
      • Is your Worker an Independent Contractor? (The IRS Cares!)
    • Wills, Trusts & Estate Planning
      • Congrats, You’ve Inherited a Mess
      • When Should I Write a Will?
      • Top 5 Reasons to Change Your Will
    • Prenuptial Agreements
      • Recently Engaged? 5 Reasons Why You Should Consider A Prenup
    • Other Practice Areas
      • Indemnification in Contracts: What if Both Parties Are at Fault?
      • Indemnification in Contracts: Should You at Least Have to be Guilty as Charged?
      • Venue Clauses in Contracts – Beware Listing Only the County and State
    • Limited Scope Services
      • Arbitration Agreement: How to Get to Arbitration if A Lawsuit Was Filed First
      • Follow the Contract’s Arbitration Clause or File a Lawsuit?
      • Arbitration: setting the rules and identifying which arbitration organization will be used
      • Why does your Corporation or Company Need a Registered Agent?
  • Who We Are
    • Jason A. McGrath
    • James M. Spielberger
    • Kelly J. Brown
    • Todd E. Gonyer
    • Trent Grissom
  • Where We Practice
  • Client Services
    • Helpful Resources
    • News & Updates
  • Consultations
    • About McGrath & Spielberger’s Intake Form

Coronavirus, Force Majeure, and Your Business Contract – Will the Charlotte Hornets and Other NBA Players Be Paid?

Posted on March 30, 2020August 14, 2023 by g83js92js91
Categories: Uncategorized
The coronavirus (more formally known as COVID-19) is now impacting every part of life. In our last blog post, we discussed general issues on how coronavirus might impact your business contract, and pointed out that the effects of this disease are impacting whether people are getting paid. The NBA just suspended its games for the immediate future – what about NBA players while the National Basketball Association’s games are suspended? Are Mr. Michael Jordan and the Charlotte Hornets obligated to pay players like Devonte Graham, Terry Rozier, Dwayne Bacon, and PJ Washington? Must the Warriors provide contractual wages to Steph Curry? Let’s explore how we might find the answers.

What contract controls the relationship between the National Basketball Association and its teams like the Boston Celtics on the one side and players like Kemba Walker on the other? The relationship between the NBA, the teams, and the players is generally governed by contract law, and specifically a business contract almost 600 pages long titled the “Collective Bargaining Agreement” (the “CBA”).

What key part of the CBA might largely control what happens in these coronavirus-induced circumstances? What immediately comes to mind is whether there is a “Force Majeure” clause somewhere in those many pages of fine legal verbiage. Click here for a brief recap of what a Force Majeure clause is; in essence, some unusual, significant condition beyond the control of a contractual party which interferes with that party’s ability to perform duties under the contract. Yep, on page 467 is “Section 5: Termination by NBA/Force Majeure”.

Is something like COVID-19 addressed in the CBA under the Force Majeure clause? Notably, the list of Force Majeure items in the NBA’s contract with the National Basketball Players Association [sic] does include “epidemics”. That term is not defined specifically in the CBA, which means we’d typically look to the standard definition, perhaps influenced by what definitions relevant courts of law have accepted over time. “Epidemic: a disease affecting many persons at the same time, and spreading from person to person in a locality where the disease is not permanently prevalent.” Very few reasonable minds would disagree that coronavirus is an epidemic in the United States right now (and in Canada to a certain extent, let’s not forget the reigning NBA champion Toronto Raptors).

You should also know that the Collective Bargaining Agreement – which, again, is a business contract – allows the NBA to terminate that contract after a Force Majeure event.

So does coronavirus mean that the NBA doesn’t have to pay the players while games are suspended? There may be an epic battle over that very question.  The CBA specifically states that if a Force Majeure event (like coronavirus – an “epidemic”) occurs and causes teams not to be able to play one or more games, and those games are not made up, each player who was part of that team shall have his overall compensation for that season reduced by 1.08%. (In the contract it’s actually expressed as a fraction – 1/92.6th, based on an agreement that for this purpose a season is made up of 92.6 games.)

Interestingly, this part of the CBA specifically states that neither the NBA nor the Players Association must terminate the contract even if it has the right to do so, including as to the NBA’s right to cancel the CBA due to this Force Majeure event. However, there is not similar language which specifically addresses whether the NBA has the option to reduce compensation to the players under a Force Majeure circumstance. Thus we are left with language mentioned in the previous paragraph (and in the CBA itself, the previous page) which says that the players’ compensation “shall” be reduced.

If I was arguing for non-payment, I’d argue that the contract doesn’t allow the teams to pay the players in these circumstances even if the teams wanted to. The players, presumably, would argue that a contractual party always has the right not to enforce one of its rights, and thus the teams could of course pay the players if they so choose. Also, there are certainly other aspects of this 598-page contract, governed by New York and/or Federal law, which influence these legalities, and this article is not attempting to engage in a detailed analysis of this issue and is not attempting to interpret or comment on New York law.

This NBA stuff is interesting, but what about my business? Can your lawyers help my company deal with contract issues? Yes, that’s what we do. We explore, we troubleshoot, we diagnose, we advise, we repair, we resolve, we combat, whichever is appropriate. If you want help and the subject matter and the jurisdiction (which state, etc.) match up with those of our Firm, reach out to us and ask for a consultation; one way to do so is by clicking here. Good luck and keep yourself – and your business – safe!

McGrath and Spielberger, PLLC handles business law and contract law matters every day, and has lawyers who are licensed to practice in FL, GA, NC, OH, SC, and TN (if you are unsure as to what jurisdiction applies to your legal matter, we can help make that determination).

Posted in Uncategorized

Post navigation

Previous: Coronavirus, Force Majeure, and Your Business Contract Explained
Next: Commercial Leases in South Carolina Amid the Covid-19 Coronavirus Pandemic

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Business Ownership Deals (Part 6 of Series): How Many Different Attorneys Need To Be Involved?
  • Business Ownership Deals: Buying And Selling (Transferring) Membership Interests In LLCs – Part 5, Filings With The Secretary Of State
  • Business Ownership Deals: Buying And Selling (Transferring) Membership Interests In LLCs – Part 4, Operating Agreement (“OA”) Changes
  • Business Ownership Deals: Buying And Selling (Transferring) Membership Interests In LLCs – Part 3, The Company Resolution
  • Business Ownership Deals: Buying And Selling (Transferring) Membership Interests In LLCs (Part 2)

McGrath & Spielberger, PLLC

Tweets by JasonMcGrathLaw

Sitemap

  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Who We Are
  • Where We Practice
  • Consultations
  • Blog

What We Do

  • Business & Contract Law
  • Limited Liability Company
  • Mortgage & Foreclosure
  • Real Estate Cases
  • Disputes & Lawsuits
  • Tax & IRS Matters
  • Wills, Trusts & Estate Planning
  • Prenuptial Agreements
  • Other Practice Areas
  • Business Compliance Services

Location

Directions

Contact Us

7300 Carmel Executive Park Drive, Suite 300, Charlotte, NC 28226

info@mcgrathspielberger.com

1.800.481.2180


fb


tw


yt


ld

google

The attorneys responsible for this website are Jason McGrath and Jim Spielberger. At least some of the content of this website may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions. For information about our website privacy policy and terms and conditions, please click here.

Attorney Website Design, Legal Search Engine Optimizations and Lawyer Online Advertising by Leads Online Marketing Services.